Indexing, rapid growth and surgical thresholds by condition, fetus to adult
Measurement convention. Children: inner edge to inner edge in systole (AHA 2024, MM 2024). Adult echo: leading edge to leading edge in end-diastole (ESC 2024, I, C). PHN and Boston nomograms use inner edge in systole. Adult CT or CMR: inner edge to inner edge in end-diastole (ESC 2024, I, C). ACC/AHA 2022 (IIa) names no phase; its normal data are end-diastolic. Systole reads about 2 mm larger (ESC 2024).
| Degree | <16 y: Z score | ≥16 y: max diameter (cm) |
|---|---|---|
| None | <2 | <3.5 |
| Mild | ≥2 and <3.5 | ≥3.5 and <4 |
| Moderate | ≥3.5 and <5 | ≥4 and <4.5 |
| Severe | ≥5 | ≥4.5 |
| Age | Index | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Fetal | Root measurement not standard; no fetal threshold in the sources read. | AHA 2024 |
| Child | BSA Z score, the same nomogram at every study. | AHA 2024 |
| Adult | Ascending dilated ≥4.0 cm, aneurysm ≥4.5 cm. Index to height or BSA (IIa): ASI cm/m², AHI cm/m, area/height ≥10 cm²/m. | ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Age | Definition | Source |
|---|---|---|
| <2 y | ≥0.8 cm/y (high risk) | AHA 2024 Table 1 |
| ≥2 y | ≥0.5 cm/y (high risk) AHA 2024 Tables 2–3 footnotes (rapid or moderately rapid growth): ≥0.5 and <0.8 cm/y before 2 y; >0.3 and <0.5 cm/y after 2 y. Table 2: more frequent monitoring may be considered; Table 3 (moderately rapid): more aggressive medical therapy may be considered. | AHA 2024 Table 1 |
| Adult height | >0.3 cm/y for 2 consecutive years | AHA 2024 Table 1 |
| Child | Marfan: >5 mm/yr with Z increase >1 SD | MM 2024 |
| Adult | HTAD or BAV: ≥0.3 cm in 1 y ACC/AHA 2022: sporadic, and nonsyndromic HTAD high risk (Table 9): ≥0.5 cm in 1 y or ≥0.3 cm/y in 2 consecutive y. Marfan and BAV tables: ≥0.3 cm/y; LDS footnote: >0.3 cm/y. | ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Adult | ≥3 mm per year; confirm a TTE increase by CT or CMR (IIa, C) A risk factor in the ESC 2024 surgery recommendations for Marfan, LDS, ACTA2, BAV and Turner (Figure 40); the Marfan footnotes add “in adults”. | ESC 2024 |
| Adult | After arterial switch: >3 mm/year Children with repaired CHD: the AHA 2024 Table 1 growth criteria are not stated for them; imaging per lesion (Table 2). | ACC/AHA 2025 ACHD |
Diagnosis (revised Ghent) and Z scores: Aortic Root and Ghent Experimental.
| Age | Threshold | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Early-onset | Severe dilation, aortic valve annulus ≥2 (unit not printed): <2 y 3.3–3.4 cm; ≥2 and <5 y 3.7–3.8 cm; ≥5 y 4 cm | AHA 2024 Table 5 |
| Child | High-risk features AHA 2024 Table 1: family history of dissection (especially <5 cm), family surgery or dissection in childhood, aortic valvar dysfunction, moderate or greater; rapid growth; pregnancy; early-onset Marfan, vertebral tortuosity index >50. | AHA 2024 Table 5 |
| Child | Standard: 5.0 or maximum cross-sectional aortic area/height (cm²/m) ≥10, age ≥16 y† As printed in AHA 2024 Table 5 (no sign before 5.0). It is unclear whether “age ≥16 y” governs both criteria or only the area/height index. †Indexing for children much smaller or taller than average. | AHA 2024 Table 5 |
| Child | Recommended at 50 mm; considered at 45 mm with family history of dissection, growth >5 mm/yr or valve surgery Agreement 100% (50 mm) and 83% (45 mm). Valve-sparing surgery preferred (92%). | MM 2024 |
| Adult | Root ≥5.0 cm: replace root and ascending aorta | I B-NR ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Adult | Root ≥4.5 cm with risk features ACC/AHA 2022 Table 10: family history of dissection; growth ≥0.3 cm/y; diffuse root and ascending dilation; marked vertebral arterial tortuosity. Experienced surgeons in a Multidisciplinary Aortic Team. | IIa B-NR ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Adult | Root, maximal sinus ≥50 mm; ≥45 mm with risk factors ESC 2024 Recommendation Table 62: family history of dissection at small diameters (<50 mm); resistant hypertension (three or more drugs); growth ≥3 mm per year in adults. Valve-sparing replacement of root and ascending aorta when the valve can be preserved and the surgeon has the expertise (I, B). | I B ESC 2024 |
| Drug | Dose | Maximum |
|---|---|---|
| Atenolol | 1–4 | 250 mg |
| Propranolol | 0.75–3 | 160 mg |
| Metoprolol | 1–2 | 200 mg |
| Bisoprolol | 0.05 | 10 mg |
| Losartan | 0.7–1.4 | 50 mg ≤50 kg; 100 mg >50 kg |
| Irbesartan | 1–2 | 150 mg ≤50 kg; 300 mg >50 kg |
| Valsartan | 1–4 | 80 mg ≤35 kg; 160 mg 35–80 kg; 320 mg ≥80 kg |
| Enalapril | 0.1–1 | 20 mg |
| Captopril | 0.3–6 | 100 mg |
| Gene | Standard | High-risk features |
|---|---|---|
| TGFBR1, TGFBR2 | ≥4.5 | Annulus ≥2: <2 y 3.3–3.4; ≥2 and <5 y 3.7–3.8; ≥5 y 4.0 |
| TGFB2 | ≥4.5 | ≥4.5 |
| TGFB3 | ≥5.0 | ≥5.0 |
| SMAD3, SMAD2 | ≥4.5 | ≥4.5 |
| Gene | Diameter | Class |
|---|---|---|
| TGFBR1, TGFBR2, no high-risk features | ≥4.5 | I C-LD |
| TGFBR2, high risk | ≥4.0 | IIa C-LD |
| TGFBR1, high risk | ≥4.0 | IIb C-EO |
| SMAD3 | ≥4.5 | IIa C-EO |
| TGFB2 | ≥4.5 | IIb C-EO |
| TGFB3 | ≥5.0 | IIb C-EO |
| LDS, no gene specified (ESC 2024) | >45 mm ESC 2024: the threshold may be adjusted to the gene, taking high-risk features into account (IIb, C); its text gives ≥40 mm with high-risk features. High-risk features: specific variants; women with TGFBR2 variants and small body size; severe extra-aortic features; family history of dissection; growth ≥3 mm per year. | IIa C |
| Age | Threshold | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Child | Root or ascending ≥4.5 cm, standard and high risk (only vEDS number found) | AHA 2024 Table 5 |
| Adult | No diameter threshold for prophylactic surgery: no data (no class); case by case | ACC/AHA 2022 text; ESC 2024 |
| Gene | Standard | High-risk features |
|---|---|---|
| ACTA2 | ≥4.5 | ≥4.2 Larger thresholds if cerebral flow is compromised. ACTA2 R179 (smooth muscle dysfunction syndrome): insufficient data; “consider using early Marfan syndrome numbers”. |
| PRKG1 | Surgery at age ≥17 years with any dilation (Z ≥2) | |
| MYH11 | ≥4.5 | ≥4.5 |
| MYLK | No number: no childhood events reported; discuss with an aortopathy expert | |
| LOX, FLNA | ≥5.0 | Consider earlier |
| EFEMP2 | None established; use TGFBR1/2 high-risk criteria | |
| SLC2A10 (arterial tortuosity) | ≥5.0 | NA (no dissections reported) |
| No diagnosis | ≥5.0 | ≥4.5 |
| Gene | No risk factors | Risk factors |
|---|---|---|
| ACTA2 | ≥4.5 IIa C-LD | ≥4.2 IIb C-EO |
| ACTA2 (ESC 2024) | ≥45 mm, or lower with risk factors ESC 2024 Recommendation Table 67 risk factors: family history of dissection with no or minimal dilatation or at young age; growth ≥3 mm per year. No lower number is given. Annual TTE (I, C); CMR or CT every 3–5 years (I, C). | |
| PRKG1 | ≥4.2 IIb C-LD | ≥4.0 IIb C-EO |
| Familial (nsHTAD), no gene found; no family diameter data | ≥5.0 I C-LD | ≥4.5 IIa C-LD |
Adult Sporadic dilation (ACC/AHA 2022 6.5.1): surgery ≥5.5 cm (I, B-NR); ≥5.0 cm at an aortic team (IIa, B-NR).
| Age | Threshold | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Child | ≥5.5 cm; high risk ≥5.0 cm; with aortic valve repair or replacement, concomitant replacement reasonable at ≥4.5 cm | AHA 2024 Table 5 |
| Adult | ≥5.5 cm | I B-NR ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Adult | 5.0–5.4 cm with a risk factor; area/height ≥10 cm²/m; ≥4.5 cm during aortic valve surgery (ESC 2024 ≥45 mm: IIa, C) | IIa B-NR ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Adult | 5.0–5.4 cm, no risk factor, low surgical risk | IIb B-NR ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Adult | ≥55 mm; root phenotype ≥50 mm | I B ESC 2024 |
| Adult | Ascending phenotype, low surgical risk: >52 mm; ≥50 mm with a risk factor (IIa, C) ESC 2024 Recommendation Table 68, any of: age <50 years; height 1.50–1.69 m; ascending length ≥11 cm; growth ≥3 mm per year; family history of acute aortic syndrome; coarctation; resistant hypertension; concomitant non-aortic-valve cardiac surgery; desire for pregnancy. Root phenotype: sinus wider than the tubular aorta; ascending phenotype: tubular wider than the sinus. | IIa B ESC 2024 |
| Age | Index and threshold | Source |
|---|---|---|
| <15 y | Turner-specific Z score; thresholds and calculator: Turner Aortic Z Experimental | ACC/AHA 2022 |
| ≥15 y | Index by ASI (I, B-NR). Surgery: ASI ≥2.5 cm/m² with risk factors (IIa, C-LD), without (IIb, C-EO) | ACC/AHA 2022 |
| ≥15 y | Surgery: ASI >23 mm/m², AHI >23 mm/m, Z >3.5 with risk factors ESC 2024 Recommendation Table 58 risk factors: BAV, elongated transverse aorta, coarctation, hypertension uncontrolled on more than three drug classes. The table lists ASI, AHI and Z together without saying whether one or all must be met. Its text: root surgery before pregnancy is recommended when ASI reaches 25 mm/m² (no class). Index by ASI, AHI or Z (I, C); surveillance intervals by ASI and concomitant lesions (I, C). | ESC 2024 |
AHA 2024 excludes Turner; ACHD 2025 has no Turner recommendation.
| Age | Threshold | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Child | TGA, truncus, TOF, PA-VSD, Fontan: ≥5.5–6.0 cm. Previous Ross: ≥5.0–6.0 cm Institutional practice varies; Ross is often done in children with BAV, so the threshold may be lower. | AHA 2024 Table 5 |
| Adult | Arterial switch: neoaortic root replacement may be considered Severe neoaortic root dilation with progressive neoaortic insufficiency and/or rapid growth, or a planned neoaortic valve intervention. | IIb B-NR ACC/AHA 2025 ACHD |
| Adult | TOF, arterial switch, Fontan, Ross: no numeric threshold (evidence gap) | ACC/AHA 2025 ACHD |
Child Pregnancy is a high-risk feature in children (AHA 2024 Table 1). ACC/AHA 2022 rows are written for patients of any age; ESC 2024 rows for adults (Turner: women ≥15 y).
| Condition | Threshold | Class, source |
|---|---|---|
| Marfan | Root >4.5 cm | I C-LD ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Marfan | 4.0–4.5 cm, especially with growth ≥0.3 cm/y or family history of dissection | IIb C-LD ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Marfan | Adult Aortic diameter >45 mm (40–45 mm: IIb, C) | I C ESC 2024 |
| TGFB2, TGFB3 | ≥4.5 cm | IIa C-EO ACC/AHA 2022 |
| TGFBR1, TGFBR2, SMAD3 | ≥4.0 cm | IIb C-EO ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Nonsyndromic HTAD | ≥4.5 cm (4.0–4.4 cm: IIb, C-EO) | I C-EO ACC/AHA 2022 |
| BAV | ≥5.0 cm | I C-EO ACC/AHA 2022 |
| BAV | Adult Ascending phenotype ≥50 mm with desire for pregnancy, low surgical risk | IIa C ESC 2024 |
| Turner | ASI ≥2.5 cm/m² (Table 34 prints >2.5) | I C-LD ACC/AHA 2022 |
| Turner | Planning pregnancy: ASI >23 mm/m², AHI >23 mm/m, Z >3.5 (its text, no class: recommended at ASI 25 mm/m²) | IIa C ESC 2024 |